920-722-7741
OPEN MENU

The Debatable Start of the Iconic Ice Cream Sundae

Nov 11, 2026 | Insights

How soda fountains, Sunday traditions, and hometown rivalries shaped an American classic

A boy and his mom eating ice cream sundaes together

Few desserts are as instantly recognizable as an ice cream sundae: a scoop or two topped with a flavored sauce, whipped cream, maybe some nuts, and a bright red cherry. On National Sundae Day we thought this is the perfect time to share the story of this American ice cream treat born during the age of the soda fountain. While its birthplace remains unconfirmed, it doesn’t stop us from enjoying them.

Soda Fountains and the Creation of Sundaes

In the late 1800s, drugstores were a place to fill prescriptions as well as meet friends, family, and community members. Soda fountains served carbonated drinks with flavors, ice cream sodas, and other sweet drinks. Ice cream was becoming more widely available as refrigeration improved, while chocolate and fruit syrups were already being used as fountain ingredients.

Many enjoyed going to drugstores for a special ice cream soda, however in some cities soda could not be sold on Sundays. Consumption of soda was restricted out of respect for the day, considered a holy day of rest in some religions. Because of this, soda fountains looked for ways to sell their ice cream without soda, hence the sundae was created. Fountain owners removed the soda water and topped the ice cream with any variety of syrups they had. This simple change respected religious observance and was done in the spirit of innovation of the time.

The Birthplace of Sundaes is Still Unknown

While there isn’t an exact date for the start of the sundae, Two Rivers, Wisconsin claims the dessert was created in 1881. According to locals, George Hallauer asked soda-fountain owner Edward Berners to pour chocolate sauce over a dish of ice cream. Berners then began selling the combination for a nickel, first on Sundays and then throughout the week. Generations have kept this version of the story alive, despite later documentation of the event.

Ithaca, New York, offers a later but more thoroughly documented claim for the start. On April 3, 1892, pharmacist Chester Platt served the Reverend John M. Scott vanilla ice cream topped with cherry syrup and a candied cherry after church. The treat was called a “Cherry Sunday.” Two days later, Platt & Colt Pharmacy advertised the dish in the Ithaca Daily Journal—the oldest known advertisement naming a frozen treat of this sort. Strawberry and chocolate versions soon followed, and Platt later explored trademark protection for the name.

Evanston, Illinois, and other communities tried owning the start of the sundae as well. Fountain operators were serving ice cream and syrup with respect for Sunday. Because the ingredients were common at most drugstores and soda fountains, it is possible that similar dishes were found in several towns.

How “Sunday” Became “Sundae”

The spelling of the ice cream treat is often debated as well. One explanation is soda fountain owners changed “Sunday” to avoid offending religious groups. Another claims competitors wanted to sidestep Platt’s ownership of the original name. Lastly, it could have been a marketing or advertising ploy. By the early 1900s, however, “sundae” had become the standard spelling, separating the tie to the calendar.

The change turned a Sunday treat into an anytime indulgence. Many fountain operators started to innovate, too. And, because the sauces had an appealing appearance against the glass, glass manufacturers produced tall, fluted dishes, turning presentation into part of the experience as well.

From Fountain Treat to American Icon

As soda fountains became more successful, the sundae became an affordable social ritual. Teenagers met over them, families ordered them after shopping trips, and drugstores used their unique flavors and ideas to bring customers to the store. The banana split, generally credited to the early 1900s, expanded the formula by adding fruit, multiple scoops, and several sauces. Hot fudge, brownie, and regional sundaes quickly followed.

The popularity of the classic soda fountain declined after World War II as restaurants, grocery stores, and freezers changed American eating habits. The sundae survived due to its adaptable structure: ice cream, sauce, and a topping. Today, sundaes feature salted caramel, cereal, or nostalgic candies, to name a few, and the ideas keep coming.

Whether the first was chocolate-topped in Wisconsin or cherry-topped in New York, the sundae’s history is a story of American imagination. More than a century later, every dish carries a little of that delicious mystery.

Creating Sundaes at Scale

Whether you own an ice cream business or are part of a larger operation, selecting a versatile base for your ice cream products is critical. Classic Mix offers mixes formulated to deliver a smooth, creamy texture and rich flavor, providing a consistent quality that ice cream shops and frozen dessert manufacturers can rely on. The customizable nature of these mixes allows for creation of a wide array of flavors and textures to meet diverse consumer preferences.

Let’s talk about how Classic Mix can support your ice cream creations and operations and be part of the perfect sundae.

Ready to Partner with Us?

At Galloway Company, we’re all about building relationships and working together to craft exceptional dairy ingredients. Whether you’re interested in learning more about our products, exploring partnership opportunities, or simply have a question, we’d love to hear from you!

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
City/State or Region

Dive into Delicious 

Ready for Some Dairy Delight? 

Reach out to Galloway Company and let’s create something extraordinary together. If you’re curious about our ingredients, we’re here to help.